The choice for ham or turkey at Thanksgiving is easy; turkey. But for the side dishes such as mashed potatoes, stuffing, homemade or store cranberries, mac-and-cheese, and green bean casserole, the preferences may surprise you.

If you’re in charge of providing pie, which should you bring? If you want the most popular pie and guessed pumpkin, you’re wrong, as I was.

According to Buzzfeed, apple is the most popular, at 39%. Pumpkin pie is the second favorite by  37%. What I guessed in second place, pecan pie is in third place and bringing up the rear, cherry is in fourth position with just 7 percent claiming it their favorite.